Frank Bryce's Death - query

Barry Arrowsmith arrowsmithbt at kneasy.yahoo.invalid
Wed Jun 20 12:55:19 UTC 2007


--- In the_old_crowd at yahoogroups.com, "mooseming" <josturgess at ...> wrote:
>
> I've been reviewing DD's HRX identification and have come across an 
> *error* which is bugging me and for which I can see no *obvious* 
> implications.
> 
> DD says Voldy got the idea of using Nagini as a HRX after Voldy used 
> her to "kill an old muggle man" for which I take it he meant Frank 
> Bryce in the opening of GoF.  Yet DD *knows* Voldy used his wand for 
> that murder as Harry reports his appearance during the Priori 
> Incantatem incident.
> 
> Is there another death to which DD is refering that I've forgotten 
> about? If not why would DD make this error?
> 

Options:

1. It's not Frank Bryce he's on about.

2. DD's guessing.

3. For reasons yet unknown DD's pulling the wool over Harry's eyes again.

4. For reasons yet unknown Jo's pulling the wool over our eyes.

5. Jo's lost the plot.

Kneasy





More information about the the_old_crowd archive