The Beard
davewitley
dfrankiswork at davewitley.yahoo.invalid
Mon May 19 14:26:18 UTC 2008
Gatta:
> I have read and reread the original texts and searched the early
depictions of Snape, including JKR's own drawing
(http://www.katmac.cncdsl.com/Rowling_Snape.jpg), and nowhere do I
find a trace of whiskers. (Quite a lot of hair in the case of the JKR
drawing, but a well defined chin and as far as I can tell, no beard.)
>
> Yes, the American illustrator drew Snape with that silly little Fu
Manchu beard, but I've always set that down to personal aberration,
nothing to do with the Canon. I thought she missed the mark on quite
a lot of things, not just Snape's facial fur.
I remember a while ago (2003?) Grandpre did some sort of event in
Salt Lake City and a bunch of HPFGUers went along and asked the hard
questions. One of them (Foxydoxy? Dooda? Dicentra?) reported back on
OT-Chatter, and as I recall Grandpre was totally nonplussed: she had
just assumed all along he had a beard and was astonished to be picked
up on it.
I think the consensus has always been clean-shaven.
David
More information about the the_old_crowd
archive