QUESTIONS ON CATEGORY 0 – REJECTS

[a_reader2003]

I am starting off our Category list discussion with a series of 
posts, divided up by the sections of the list for convenience. Look 
forward to your responses!
Carolyn

CATEGORY 0 - REJECTS


(0.5) Listings of personal favourite topics/characters etc
I have been using this for much unsupported `I wish' type posts, 
eg `I hope Harry/Hermione/Ron etc get it together in the end', as 
well as `I love xxx in the books'. The only exception here where 
someone is appreciating the humour in the series, where I have been 
coding under 1.3.6 (if I agree!).

(0.8) Mere agreement/adding nothing new 
This category is likely to be increasingly important as we move 
forwards. Should it be split in two? What should our criteria be 
for `adding nothing new'? I have been using it for both factual 
queries like `Where did the twins get the Marauders' Map?/ (answer) 
>From Filch's cabinet', and repetitions of common theories like `I 
think Voldemort and Harry are related' (unaccompanied by any detailed 
analysis). However, using it like this will depend on constant review 
of what has already come up.