Next set, fanfic discussion, and a missing theory

corinthum kakearney at comcast.net
Wed Feb 2 22:33:14 UTC 2005


Just finished my set of posts.

In this past set, there was a thread discussing the merits of 
fanfiction, and whether it was a valid interpretation of the books 
and consistent with authorial intent or not.  I rejected it all as 
Fanfic-related, but on second thought, perhaps that rejection 
category is for discussion of specific fanfic rather than the topic 
of fanfic?  Could those posts be valid discussion (authorial intent, 
reader response, etc)?  Let me know what everyone thinks, and I'll go 
back and re-categorize those if necessary. 

Also, Carolyn, I couldn't find a theory on the list; perhaps it 
should be added? "Reverse Memory Charm Jobberknoll Variant With 
Optional Snape and Moody".  :) Hey, it was capitalized, so it counts, 
right?

Also, for a quick laugh, read the P.S. in post 38988.

-Kelly








More information about the HPFGU-Catalogue archive