Wands/Priori Incantatem/GH

dungrollin spotthedungbeetle at hotmail.com
Sun Feb 27 13:27:19 UTC 2005


'3.8.3 Wands' is full of all sorts:
What happened to Voldy's wand after GH?
Does a wand get transformed along with an animagus?
Why doesn't Hagrid get a new wand now that he's cleared, and how 
come his old one works if it's been snapped?
Why does Charlie need a new wand?
How come some people can use others' wands?

Which is more or less all going to stay (thought there's quite a lot 
of repetition - so lots to axe). Oh, and I'm chucking lots of stuff 
into wandless magic that shouldn't be under wands. 

However, there's also a lot of discussion about the order that James 
and Lily come out of Voldy's wand in the priori incantatem. Should 
it all be dumped into 3.8.4.4 Priori Incantatem (with apologies to 
whoever is doing that category)? The posts are generally also coded 
to 1.3.5.1 Godric's Hollow/Death of Lily & James, though it's not 
really discussion of what happened, more arguing about the evidence 
from PI. 

I'm certain that PI order shouldn't be under 'wands' - but where 
should it go? Since the error was changed by JKR, do we need to keep 
it at all? Can I dump it all into 3.8.4.4 PI (where I assume 
there's a lot more discussion that hasn't been coded to wands too) 
so the ones to axe can be decided by someone with a clearer picture 
of what's already included in the catalogue? Or, is that category 
already being worked on, so I can have some new rules as to what 
should go in and what should stay out?

Advice please.







More information about the HPFGU-Catalogue archive