From Kelly/ re section 3.15.4.5

[carolynwhite2]

3.15.4.5 House championship, points system & house cup
------------------------------------------------------
Originally: 128
Now: 77

In addition to general speculation and clarification about the inner 
workings of the Hogwarts points system, this category contains much 
discussion of specific incidences of point-giving and -taking 
(fairness, arbitrariness, etc).  Most of the posts I cut were due to 
either too much personal opinion or repetitiveness (especially 
regarding the final cup presentation in PS/SS; the fairness of 
Dumbledore's actions has been debated to death).

-Kelly

PS Kelly has sent me an Excel file which lists the decisions on this 
section, which she describes as follows:

The table consists of all the post info in displayed on the [s] page 
for the category, with an additional column for the review status.

   0: no action required
   r: remove the category being reviewed
   m: move post to from review category to listed category

I'll only use the m option to move posts within categories I'm 
reviewing. Otherwise, I'll list the reject and add additional 
suggested moves in parentheses.

C - I will need to implement all these decisions on our database, as 
Kelly is working on a copy.