[HPFGU-Catalogue] Re: Preliminary Lupin

[Ginger]

C:  You need to refer to the InishAlley listing for the source post. I 
just ran my eye down the list and the oldest Lupin acronym seems to 
be post 57900 (SLURP), and the majority are in the 28000-39000 group 
of posts, so we should have picked them all up by now.


G: I have my handy dandy printout of Inish Alley sitting close by.  SLURP and Persil Automatic were both empty at the time, but I know I coded to PA last night.  

C:
This is an interesting first test of a rule we were going to 
implement. If an acronym generated under 5 posts, we were going to 
fold it back into a character head, or a sub-category head, rather 
than give it so much prominence.


G:  Good by me.  LIDS, MARATHON SWIMMER and MARATHON SWIMMER'S EYELIDS currently have one post each, and it is the same post, generating and explaining the acronyms.  ROTWEILER OF SWITCH also has that post coded to it as well as one other which does an indepth look at the theory.  Unless I find others that are keepable and codable, I say we cut them.  I'll let you know on that.


C:The technical response to this (adding the Lupin code) is that there is no need to code to 
the main head if a sub-category is coded. The system automatically 
knows that something is Lupin if a post has a tick from any of his 
sub-categories.

So, ok to do this if it makes your sort-out easier, but no need to 
retain the coding subsequently.

G:  yes, this is temporary to help me review more sanely and efficiently.  

I was thinking that in the end I would remove the Lupin heading from those that were totally ESE! or Good arguements and nothing else.  But I'm over 900 posts from that point.

C: This came up before when KathyW did ESE!McGonagall, and it worked 
well to create a sub-category within the character, but de-check them 
from the general ESE category.


G:  RogerWilco- will do (unless they are talking about ESE as a reader response).


C:  Hope this helps.

G:  Yes, very much.

Ginger, who plans to do a pre-review this weekend and weed out the obvious rejects so she can get to the meat of it later, perhaps during the full moon.


		
---------------------------------
Discover Yahoo!
 Find restaurants, movies, travel & more fun for the weekend. Check it out!
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://archive.hpfgu.org/pipermail/hpfgu-catalogue/attachments/20050607/b07ca525/attachment.html>