Preliminary Lupin

[Debbie]

--- In HPFGU-Catalogue at yahoogroups.com, "carolynwhite2" 
<carolynwhite2 at a...> wrote:
> I don't think Debbie has yet reviewed the ESE! section (1.2.4.4), but 
> I suspect that it should be divested of posts about a specific 
> character being ESE, and only contain posts that talk about ESE as a 
> so-called subversive style of reading. In the same way, posts should 
> only be in the Faith section (1.2.4.2) when they are talking about 
> reading the series at face value, or believing the author.
> 
> This came up before when KathyW did ESE!McGonagall, and it worked 
> well to create a sub-category within the character, but de-check them 
> from the general ESE category.

I did review 1.2.4.4. back when I was doing Authorial Intent/Subversive 
Readings.  I'm at work so I can't check right now, but I believe I 
concluded that the best use of the category was to code the initial 
ESE! posts for each allegedly ESE! character so we'd have them in one 
place.  Unlike Lupin, most of them don't have their own subcategory, so 
it made sense to capture all the ESE! allegations someplace.  But 
follow-up posts and rebuttals shouldn't be coded there.

Does this help?

::makes note to self to double-check the category to make sure I 
actually finished the ESE! cleanup::

Debbie