Time turning/Good n'evil/revenge..

[carolynwhite2]

KathyW:
>James was hardly the type to be faithful and Hermione was the 
product of his affair with a Muggle.

Debbie:
Wait a minute! I thought *Neville* was James' love-child. And his mom 
was Florence.

C - aargh..just look at the time-turning theories if you think it 
gets wild. Can't begin to summarise the nonsense, but would just like 
to draw people's attentions to REDHEAD ALWAYS, TTTR and BALDERDASH. 
These are good place to put time theories rather than stashing them 
under 'Time turner/travel/ or the character main headings.

*********

Debbie:
L.I.G.H.T.N.I.N.G. is misspelled in the catalogue. There is no E.

C- will correct.

*****************
Dicentra:

I've been keeping all those posts that discuss in the abstract what 
constitutes Good and Evil in the Potterverse (or Good and Evil in 
general) and discarding those posts that speculate whether a 
character is good or evil and can be redeemed (unless the post also 
attempts to define Good or Evil in general). I'm in the 32000s, so 
I've not yet come to the really frenetic epoch of ESE speculation 
yet. There's a separate category for ESE, is there not?

I've also kept posts that speculate as to whether Good or Evil will 
triumph and why. I've kept some interesting threads intact.

I've discarded lots of posts that are just plain lame in their 
treatment of the topic.

C - my main interest in this section is its potential or actual 
overlap with the morality sections. How are you distinguishing good 
n'evil discussions versus eg the rule breaking stuff, and also the 
freewill/choice stuff. They frequently get discussed in the same 
posts.

*****************
Debbie:
Seriously, I've been tempted to add to the top of some of the pending 
messages I've approved, "Note to Cataloguers: Tedious repetition. 
Reject without reading."

--Dicentra, who plans to keep all her own posts intact and to discard 
those of her enemies' Bwahahaha!

C - so nice to see evidence of the calm, balanced, fair approach that 
members of Admin take when they finally get a chance for revenge.... 
not good for you, bottling it all up y'know.

*********************
Sean:
Do tell, post #'s please :) He's been snapping posters heads off 
right left and centre. He's not a bad theorist, but a touch combative.

C - Kneasy informs me that these reflect the heat of the battle from 
his side, but you need to look at how the argument built that day and 
the day before. It started off as Snape-bashing session, but then got 
very personal. All the analytically-challenged fluffies on the list 
wet their knickers in the hope that Darrin would win the day. Some 
hope - last heard of in intensive care.

http://groups.yahoo.com/group/HPforGrownups/message/101118

http://groups.yahoo.com/group/HPforGrownups/message/101183

http://groups.yahoo.com/group/HPforGrownups/message/102008

http://groups.yahoo.com/group/HPforGrownups/message/102061