Welcome to HPFGU-Feedback

[a_reader2003]

--- In HPFGU-Feedback at yahoogroups.com, Heidi Tandy <heidilist at t...> 
wrote:
> 
> A lot, though, were shocked, saddened or otherwise thrown off 
balance by 
> ootp. I probably wouldve left the fandom entirely were it not for 
nimbus 
> and fictionalley, because of my responsibilities, not to actually, 
you 
> know, discuss anything.
> 
> But in the four months since, I've realised that I actually like 
the 
> bloody tome after all. Whew and yay. 
> 
> Now...
> 
> 
> Back to TOC.
> 
> Everyone is free to discuss whatever they want to here, but if 
someone 
> again blames the fifty or so canon discussion posts on toc for 
anything, 
> I reserve the right to laugh.
> 
Carolyn:

Well, I'm so relieved to read this..I thought I'd been missing the 
cream of the TBay posts ! And I was driven to find people to talk to 
after the awfulness of Oop, I had to share my disappointment. Good to 
know many long-term members thought the same thing; its sometimes 
hard to tell. Despite the fantastically high volume since July, I 
don't regret wading through it all, as its helped me see the book in 
lots of very complex contexts.(Although I still think its poorly 
written and structured). Now, however (see my other posts), I'd 
really appreciate some help in grouping some of that stuff together, 
so as not to lose the themes.