Movie thoughts (yeah, Snape, so sue me)

kris403 at yahoo.com kris403 at yahoo.com
Sun Nov 18 03:38:41 UTC 2001


Amanda wrote:> 
> Quibbles and observations on the first viewing:
> 
> 1.     McGonagall was James' *teacher*, why is an "M. McGonagall" 
also on the plaque (as a chaser, I think, didn't catch the position) 
which shows James as Seeker?


Here's my take on this.  It's definetely not Minerva McGonagall.  
She is too old to play for the house team  :).  But remember a very 
long time ago when discussion on the main group turned to professors 
and their families?  Maybe she was married at some point and has a 
son (Mark, Mike, Murray?) or a daughter (Mary, Maggie, etc)?  Maybe 
this was a clue that JKR is going to clue us in on some of the 
professors' histories.  

JMHO,
Kris






More information about the HPFGU-Movie archive