One mystery *partially* solved!

[MMMfanfic at hotmail.com]

--- In HPFGU-Movie at y..., caliburncy at y... wrote:
> Here's the new CNN 
> quote:
> 
> > "I wrote a piece of dialogue referring to Sirius Black," -- one 
of 
> > the main figures in the third book -- and she said, 'you can't do
> > that because you will see in book five, that's not possible,' "
> > Kloves said. 
> 
> So we know now that it has something to do with Sirius Black.  
> Interesting.  I assume then that it would have been brought up at 
> some point in Hagrid's comments about where he got the motorcycle 
> (per canon--these lines were either cut or never filmed for the 
> movie).  So the new mystery is: what could Kloves have possibly 
said 
> about Black that book five will make impossible?
> 
> -Luke

It can't be about the wedding photo because Sirius was there as 
James's best man.  

I found it strange that Hagrid did not know Sirius was suppose to be 
the Potter's secret keeper.  I'm guessing that the 'you can't do 
that' might have been Dumbledore telling Hagrid about Sirius.  When 
Hagrid talked about returning the motorcycle to Sirius, Dumbledore 
didn't say anything.  Another anomaly -- Dumbledore believed Sirius 
to be guilty at the time but did not stop Hagrid looking for Sirius, 
why?

My best speculation is that it has something to do with the backstory 
between Hagrid, Dumbledore and Sirius.  May be there is some reason 
why Dumbledore didn't tell Hagrid about Sirius's role, which will be 
revealed in book 5.