One mystery *partially* solved!

[Catlady (Rita Prince Winston)]

btw WELCOME BACK, AMANDA, and tell us (on OT) all about what you and 
Sheryll got up to!

--- In HPFGU-Movie at y..., caliburncy at y... wrote:

> > "I wrote a piece of dialogue referring to Sirius Black," -- one 
> > of  the main figures in the third book -- and she said, 'you 
> > can't do that because you will see in book five, that's not 
> > possible,' " Kloves said. 
> 
> So the new mystery is: what could Kloves have possibly said 
> about Black that book five will make impossible?

H'mmmm. Book dialogue: Dumbledore asked "And where did you get that 
motorcycle?" and Hagrid replied "Young Sirius Black lent it to me." 
and Dumbledore DID NOT reply "When? Don't you know that it was Sirius 
Black who betrayed the Potters?!" and MMMfanfic could be right that 
book five reveals the reason why Dumbledore did not tell Hagrid that.

Or maybe Kloves had been thinking about the law against enchanting 
Muggle artifacts and had Hagrid say: "It's okay, I borrowed it from 
Sirius Black, and he has a permit to have a flying motorcycle" and 
book five reveals that the motorcycle was already illegal in 1980. 
Or maybe the other way around, Kloves had Dumbledore say something 
about flying motorcycles being illegal, but book 5 will reveal that 
they were legal back then.

I'd like to think that the Kloves line had something to do with 
Sirius's love life, maybe a a reference to Sirius being Harry's 
godfather and his wife or girlfriend being Harry's godmother. Such a 
line could be wrong in So Many Ways, from Kloves having said wife (or 
girlfriend) when book 5 will reveal it was girlfriend (or wife) to 
Sirius & Remus having been a well-known monogamous couple to Sirius 
having been a totally slutty single.