It's the same shop! - was: Mapping Diagon Alley
Wendy Moncur
wendy.moncur at nre.vic.gov.au
Wed May 28 23:57:00 UTC 2003
> I am unsure of the exact location of Ollivanders -
> it may be a shop or two out.
> I need to go back to the DA tour to be sure.
Ollivanders and Flourish & Blotts are in the same shop!
In the extra disc from CoS, the Diagon Alley Tour shows a shop with a
black door and a bay window either side. You can go inside. It is
Flourish & Blotts. Note the position of staircases, and the general
layout of the store. This shop is right across from a dark magenta
coloured apothecary. (This tour is the easiest way to see the shop,
because it is fairly empty of people, and you can control what you
look at)
Now go to Philosopher's stone (the movie) and run the scene where
Harry and Hagrid are in Diagon Alley - as they walk down the street.
At exactly the point where Hagrid points out Gringotts, behind his
head you see the sign on Ollivanders shop.
Later, Harry goes into Ollivanders. Notice the layout - the position
of the staircase, and the fact you can see the same apothecary
through the windows across the street.
Now play the Chamber of Secrets scene in Flourish & Blotts - the same
shop. You can see the same apothecary across the street.
Okay, maybe from a filming point of view they only built one shop
which can hold the number of actors/crew required for the bookstore
scene in CoS, so they re-dressed Ollivanders, but surely when they
originally built the set, they would have known there were scenes in
later movies that required such large spaces in other shops.
>From purely a fantasy point of view though, it does work - it IS
magic after all. If you want to go to Ollivanders, you get
Ollivanders, if you want Flourish & Blotts, you get Flourish and
Blotts. Similar to platform 9 & 3/4 - sometimes you get the platform,
sometimes you get a barrier.
So I guess the magic-powers-that-be know that Harry is 11 years old,
about to go to Hogwarts and therefore needs a wand, so it gives him
Ollivanders. Later, he doesn't need a wand, so he gets the bookstore.
Just a theory.
It does make it hard to draw a map though. :)
Change of topic: Say, did anyone else notice: in PS when Harry and
Hagrid approach the Leaky Cauldron from Muggle London, the sign
outside slowly changes from plain black to a "Leaky Cauldron" sign
they can read.
"the_crafty_turtle"
More information about the HPFGU-Movie
archive