[HPFGU-Movie] POA reveiw?

[Dolies]

> Iggy here:
> 
> Hmmm... What do I think?  The guy read the book, watched the
> trailers,
> read a couple of news stories, looked up a few pics, and wrote the
> review based on supposition.

Well that review do offer a few *new* things that none of us (who only
watched trailers/pics and on-set report) could have known, such as 
they decided to visualize the 'voices' that Harry heard from Dementors.
Lily-being-killed would be visualized in a foggy imagery instead of
just being voice. I wonder if Harry's "happy thoughts" will also be
visualized when he tried to do patronus. Also this review mentioned
"Flashback" of "kids playing the adult", does that mean the flashback
of Mauraders/Snape's school days, possibly the visualization of the
Prank incident flashback, instead having Lupin or Sirius spellling it
out in long dialogues?? Now we wouldn't know this do we? Also the
review mention that Snape did not seemed to have enter the Shrieking
Shack. That proves my theory of how the "Mother-hen Snape protecting 3
little chickens" image works. Snape never enter the shack and only
confront them when they walked out...therefore he was not knowck out. 
Well We'll know if this report is true when these things are indeed
done in how he described in the film.  ANY fan who claimed they can
write a "better" fake report need to come up with their own
"resolution" about how these things are done in the film. At least this
review offer these.

To me, the review sounds quite legit, could very well be genuine coming
from a person who's not a fan of the series but only an average reader
who read the books to his kids. He would not remember nor care for
every single details in the book, he does not hang on to nor care about
every single little detail so importantly like die hard fans do. So the
way he view the film is very much like an average film watcher, who
only focus on grand scheme of things. If a fan wrote it he/she'll
probably go on and on interpreting all these tiny bitsy details of the
trio's relationship looking for clues to support their 'ship'...that
kind of thing.

D.

__________________________________
Do you Yahoo!?
Yahoo! Mail SpamGuard - Read only the mail you want.
http://antispam.yahoo.com/tools