[HPFGU-Movie] Another observation - SPOILER

[Kathryn Wolber]

--- Brooke <sbchavez2000 at yahoo.com> wrote:
> Did anyone else get the feeling that the entire
> movie could have 
> happened in  3 days instead of a school year?  It
> didn't "feel" like 
> they were at school like the previous 2 movies did. 


Yes! That is exactly how I felt! I really think that
having Halloween and Christmas in the first to films
gave you a sense of time and time passing better than
that stupid clock. 
Also, I love how it was changed to have Hermione storm
out the same day as everything happened when in
reality she stormed out around Easter and then all the
action and Buckbeak's execution were during their
exams, so at least a month apart. 
I don't want to get into all of my complaints because
many of you have already expressed them better than I
could but the one thing I've been saying about the
movie is that every scene is amazing, but instead of
being a fluid movie its more like snippets of a movie
all thrown together with really random little
interlude scenes.  Because looking at the clips on the
internet, I still think they're brilliant, but a bunch
of good scenes haphazardly strewn together is not a
movie. 

I gave the biggest compliment I can give a movie to
Return of the King, saying that after 3 and a half
hours I wasn't bored and could have watched it over
again immediately. I give the biggest insult I can
give to PoA because for the entire movie I was bored
and knew that if, at any point in the movie, I had
left the theatre I wouldn't have looked back or cared
what happened for the rest of the film.

~Katie, who is hugely disappointed.


	
		
__________________________________
Do you Yahoo!?
Friends.  Fun.  Try the all-new Yahoo! Messenger.
http://messenger.yahoo.com/