[HPFGU-Movie] Re: Kloves or Cuaron??

[GulPlum]

At 23:19 06/06/04 , Barbara D. Poland-Waters wrote:

<snip>

>I wonder what the majority of the HP fans
>around the world really think. Personally, I would be really offended if I
>was JKR.

<snip>

Well, JKR is on record as stating that PoA is her favourite of the three to 
date, so she's hardly "offended". I think it's quite ungracious of you to 
feel that she should think the same way you do.

As for what the majority of fans around the world think, judging by the 
reaction here, it's about 70/30 in favour (that's far from being a 
scientific analysis and I remain open to correction on that point).

As only Mods can create polls on this group, in order to satisfy Barbara's 
and my curiosity (among others) may I ask that one is created along the 
following lines:

Overall, did you like PoA the Movie?
(possible answers:)
a) Yes
b) Yes, despite the plot holes
c) No
d) No, because of the plot holes

I think those options cover the basic variations of opinions voiced here 
thus far...

(For the record, a) and c) are addressed at those who like or dislike 
Cuaron's "vision" regardless of the limitations of the script.)