[HPFGU-Movie] Re: Kloves or Cuaron??

[Barbara D. Poland-Waters]

>>>From: GulPlum [mailto:hp at plum.cream.org]

Well, JKR is on record as stating that PoA is her favourite of the three to
date, so she's hardly "offended". I think it's quite ungracious of you to
feel that she should think the same way you do.

As for what the majority of fans around the world think, judging by the
reaction here, it's about 70/30 in favour (that's far from being a
scientific analysis and I remain open to correction on that point).<<<

Sorry you feel I am being ungracious, I am just stating my opinion that if
it was ME who worked so hard on creating such a beautiful, visionary world,
I would be offended to have people change it so drastically to make a movie
that appeals to the masses.

As far as your estimate of 70/30 in favor of the movie, I don't know about
that. I am subscribed to a few lists and have also been reading the comments
on IMDb, and it seems about 50/50.

Barbara
aka bd-bear
http://mysite.verizon.net/vze80gd4/