PoA expectations

[rdhdwldflwr]

--- In HPFGU-Movie at yahoogroups.com, "joj" <joj at r...> wrote:
> Hi all!  I was wondering how much our expectations played a part in 
how much we like PoA?  I personally liked this movie very much.  It 
lived up to my expectations, which were very high.  PoA though, is 
only my third favorite book.  I'm wondering if the majority of people 
who were disappointed in the movie would consider PoA their favorite 
book?
> 


I didn't like the movie much.  If I had never read the book it would 
have been alright but I think they didn't explain alot for those 
people.  POA was my favorite book.  I wasn't happy with the actor who 
played Lupine, I did like Gary Oldman.  I thought he did a good job.
What happened with Crookshanks?  He was suppose to open the tree, and 
how did Lupine and Snape know (from watching the movie) that they 
were all in the Shreiking Shack?  I also didn't like the look of the 
werewolf.  And as someone else I know say, and I agreed, we thought 
Harry was going to yell "I'm on top of the world" when he was flying 
on Buckbeak.  Too Titanic.   I'm glad this guy only got to director 
(read butcher) one movie.


"rdhdwldflwr"