Sirius: The Casting Game

doliesl doliesl at yahoo.com
Mon May 17 15:50:47 UTC 2004


The interview in Premiere magazine said they want Sirius to play by 
someone who is "iconic" of being scary, dangerous and rebellious, 
but can also be a caring person. And this speaks more about Sirius 
than "just being handsome in his glory teenage days". And so we have 
Gary Oldman. "HOT" and "CUTE (emphasis *in the past*)" is probably 
WAY at the bottom of the last of list of the priorities of Sirius 
casting (and I AGREE!). Just by going for "iconic", all the little 
known actors won't make it in first round. 

Whoever "cute" actor that someone mention here, sorry to me it is 
ineffective (and embarassing) to see some nobody on screen as 
this "infamous escaped prisoner" who is supposed to have a mythical 
frightening presence because majority of time Sirius is OFF screen, 
he is only a presence and name that scares people. Imagine when it's 
time for him to appear onscreen it'll be such a let down to see an 
actor you'd go "who? and feel "small" (and most importantly if he 
can't act well and pull some corny cheesy "ooo...I'm so scary~ I'm 
in pain" acts...btw I know nothing about that "cute" actor so of 
course I'm not saying that' he is), but you get my point: the status 
(better if he's iconic) of the actor is part of what the casting 
people concern. To all those who haven't read the book will go into 
the theatre knowing that they're supposed to fear Sirius, feeling 
his threatening presence even OFF screen. So any actor who is little 
known from acting in TV series or small budget film, won't pull off 
that GREAT presence.  Not to mention an unequal "presence" when up 
against famous "iconic to majority of audience" actors like Alan 
Rickman. The Snape/Sirius dynamic will be so one-sided as Alan 
Rickman's Snape will totally overpower a "nobody actor's Sirius" and 
makes Sirius feel small and unimportant.   

As fans I know "looks" is probably 1st MAJOR priority concern for 
most, but that won't work.

D.





More information about the HPFGU-Movie archive