What scenes do you think the movies did better than the books?

mcmaxslb McGregorMax at ec.rr.com
Tue May 18 01:19:15 UTC 2004


When PoA comes out that is one of the things we'll be talking about 
is what scenes the movie did better that the book.  I thought that we 
can practice with the first two books/movies. I have two from CoS. 

 One, When Harry visits Hermione in hospital after she is petrified 
and he sees the piece of paper in her hand that tell them about the 
Basilisk. In the movie Harry is holding her hand, trying to comfort 
her (pumpkin-y) and he feels the paper.

 The other scene is when Harry kills the Basilisk but is poisoned by 
the fang that broke off in his arm. Fawkes cures Harry with his tears 
and then Harry destroys the diary thus destroying Riddle/Voldemort. 
But in the movie first Harry destroys the diary as his last act 
taking Riddle/Voldemort with him, then Fawkes heals him. much more 
affective.

 What are yours? 






More information about the HPFGU-Movie archive