[HPFGU-Movie] Re: The Marauders' Map, was Harry and Sirius

[nicholas dean]

>
>JenD interjects:
>I have to say that I felt the "Shrieking Shack" scene was the all-time
>biggest piece of Swiss cheese (aka plotholes) that I've seen so far.


Well, yes and no. Have you reread that scene recently? A lot of 
explanation was necessary at that point, but I think JKR dragged it 
out a bit too much.

The movie went to the other extreme, cutting it too much in the 
interests of dramatic tension.

I would like to have seen something halfway between what the book 
gave us and what we saw on the screen.

>
>JenD again
>Who is ever so happy to see Nicholas back


Thank you; how nice to feel that my contributions are welcome!

Cheers,
Nicholas