Possible clues in movie lines?

Marci blackgold101 at yahoo.com
Tue Jan 18 23:17:16 UTC 2005


oneheartway_03 at m... wrote:
> 
The first one is the line stated by Dumbledore in Chamber of Secrets
when he was in Hagrid's hut. The line was directed at a (presumably)
invisable Harry and Ron prior to his leaving the hut. He said "HELP
WILL ALWAYS BE GIVEN AT HOGWARTS TO THOSE WHO....ASK FOR IT"
We see some truth to this in the same movie when Harry needs help to
defeat Riddle and the basalisk and Fawkes appears with the sorting
hat for Harry to remove the sword of Gryffindor from.

This line made no sense to my friend (who hasn't read the books but 
has seen the films).  We don't even see the truth to it in the film.  
I told her that in the book, Harry actually puts the Sorting Hat on 
his head and literally asks someone to help him.  Then the sword hits 
him on the head.

Marci







More information about the HPFGU-Movie archive