Not what they seem:
susanbones2003
rkdas at charter.net
Sun Feb 12 13:12:22 UTC 2006
--- In HPFGU-Movie at yahoogroups.com, Candle <silverstreams at ...> wrote:
>
> Jen,
>
> I like your interpretation of this. You came up with a lot of
great examples. Do you think that Harry has a special way of being
able to see past those things that may not be as they seem. He was
able to understand that Draco was not the best person to be friends
with in SS when Draco introduced himself. Draco claimed to know who
best to be associated with and Harry said that he could figure that
out for himself. Harry chooses to be friends with Ron instead and
later we see that Harry is friends with Nevil who is a very good
wizard if he could just not be so nervous. Nevil turns out to be
quite a talent in the books. In GoF Nevil is the one who finds the
solution of the Gillyweed. In GoF when they are in the maze, Harry
understands how the maze works and understands that others in the
maze are not how they show themselves. Victor is consumed by the
need to win that he starts to show an almost evil side to himself.
>
>
> Candle
>
> May there always be a light to guide you.
>
>
> [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
>
Hi,
Actually two things need clearing up. Neville is quite a talent at
herbology so FakeMoody planted the book about waterplants on him,
during their little (off screen) tea time. FakeMoody expected Harry
to turn to everyone for help and he didn't. Finally, the night
before the task, FakeMoody had to plant Neville in the library with
Harry in hopes that the two would talk about the task. I like how
this was accomplished in the book much better with Dobby's
intervention but you can't have everything. So whilst (love saying
that, makes me feel so British) Neville is a whiz at herbology, he
was not what he seemed in this instance, but a plant! (Love that
little word-play). Also, Viktor's horrible evil look inside the maze
was the result of FakeMoody's doing as well. He put Viktor under the
Imperious curse to have him take out Cedric. So Viktor was the
unwilling victim and not an evil person, but I can't remember if
Harry picked up on that in the film. I think he did. Does anyone
else remember?
Jen D.
More information about the HPFGU-Movie
archive