Not what they seem:
phoenix_kevin
phoenix_kevin at yahoo.com
Sun Feb 12 17:57:21 UTC 2006
Neville is quite a talent at
> herbology so FakeMoody planted the book about waterplants on him,
> during their little (off screen) tea time. FakeMoody expected
Harry
> to turn to everyone for help and he didn't. Finally, the night
> before the task, FakeMoody had to plant Neville in the library
with
> Harry in hopes that the two would talk about the task. I like how
> this was accomplished in the book much better with Dobby's
> intervention but you can't have everything. So whilst (love saying
> that, makes me feel so British) Neville is a whiz at herbology, he
> was not what he seemed in this instance, but a plant! (Love that
> little word-play). Also, Viktor's horrible evil look inside the
maze
> was the result of FakeMoody's doing as well. He put Viktor under
the
> Imperious curse to have him take out Cedric. So Viktor was the
> unwilling victim and not an evil person, but I can't remember if
> Harry picked up on that in the film. I think he did. Does anyone
> else remember?
> Jen D.
It was a better storline allowing Neville to suggest the solution to
Harry. It really advertised Neville's growing expertise in
Herblology and allowed him to take a larger role in the movie. Over
the entire movie series you could say Neville is becoming a great
example of "Not what you'd expect".
I hadn't realised Viktor was under the Imperious curse. It certainly
explains the almost demonic look he had. I don't remember Harry
giving any indication he knew, perhaps he did.
I was in a discussion last night where it was mentioned that James
had a lot more talent when he was Cedric's and as you said certainly
more full of himself.
More information about the HPFGU-Movie
archive