[HPFGU-Movie] Movies making Harry seem weak?

Andrea Grevera agdisney at msn.com
Sat Jan 21 02:05:25 UTC 2006



    I'm disappointed that the movie's do not show more of what Harry is 
  capable of. 
   In the SS/PS movie we have no idea that Harry can, without wand or 
  magical knowledge, grow back his hair overnight or find himself on the 
  school chimney when Dudley and his gang had been chasing him. 
    In the GOF movie Harry was not shown shaking off the imperious 
  curse.  The movie also decided to show Cedric fight off Krum in the 
  maze when indeed it was Harry who stupefied Krum.  Non book readers 
  are missing out on the subtle hints that Harry is more than he seems.  
    Shouldn't more of these hints be included in the movies?  

  Regina

  Andie:

  I agree that there is not enough detail - information-
  in the movies.  Especially in POA when things were turned
  around to suit the directors version.  I don't like it that
  the directors are not true to the book.

  Personally, and I know that I'm in the minority, but I
  liked the first 2 movies better then 3 and somewhat 4.
  The first 2 stuck to the books with minor changes.
  Book 3 put scenes wherever the director felt like it and
  4 was too rushed.  but that is MHO.

  I hope OOTP keeps to the story and doesn't leave out
  the departure of the twins.








[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]





More information about the HPFGU-Movie archive