[HPFGU-Movie] OOP movie SPOILER

[AnitaKH]

dumbledore11214 <dumbledore11214 at yahoo.com> thoughtfully gave us space:          ***************************************************

****************************************************

******************************************************

***************************************************

*****************************************************

Then wrote:

If you guys had read moview review on Leaky, one of the things they mention is that Ginny's Patronus is a Phoenix.

But if it is canon indeed, then GAH. Does it mean that Ginny is as 
powerful as Albus Dumbledore? And this is from someone who actually 
likes Ginny, but please can she be more perfect than that?

Super super powerful Ginny? I mean, phoenix implies a lot of power 
in Potterwerse, no?

  
After snipping and pruning, akh responds:
  I think perhaps you don't really have to worry about Ginny becoming the next Dumbledore in Book 7.  After a bit of rumination (hence the delay in responding here), it could be reasonably extrapolated that Ginny owes her life in CoS to Fawkes as much as she does Harry, since Fawkes provides the resources for Harry's triumph over the basilisk and hence Tom Riddle.  Given that we have no instance of a human patronus, Fawkes is the next best protector in that instance, and her only canon example of a rescue  from death.   Not to mention that Fawkes saved Harry's life, and while Ginny was only told about it in the book, she witnessed it in movie 2.
  JKR may very well have told Mr. Goldberg (isn't that his name?  I'm working from faulty memory) that Ginny's patronus is the phoenix, but we can use the simple explanation provided by Chamber of Secrets, rather than force ourselves to become all metaphysical about it.  I'm not good at metaphysics, anyway.
   
  akh, who was sure someone else would come up with the phoenix/CoS link before she got around to posting


      Recent Activity
    
      6
  New Members

Visit Your Group 
  SPONSORED LINKS
      
   Harry potter movies  
   Harry potter movie goblet of fire  
   Harry potter  
   Harry potter book  
   Harry potter birthday party

      Yahoo! Movies
  Up for a movie?
  Check out showtimes
  and buy tickets

    Yahoo! Search
  Find it faster 
  with Yahoo!
  shortcuts.

    Yahoo! TV
  American Idol
  See the newest
  show pics!



  .

 
         


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]