OOP movie SPOILER

[dumbledore11214]

--- In HPFGU-Movie at yahoogroups.com, "julie" <juli17 at ...> wrote:
>
> S************************************************
> p***********************************************
> o************************************************
> i***********************************************
> l*************************************************
> e*************************************************
> r***************************************************
> 
> S
> p
> a
> c
> e
> 
> !
> !
> !
> !
> !
> !
> 
> > Julie:
> From what I've read the scriptwriter (forgot his name) did 
> press JKR to give him any suggestions/notes on the script,
> and she did insert a few bits, but mostly gave him free 
> rein. She certainly read the script, and though I do think
> she views the books and movies as two separate entities in
> most ways, if something was completely out of order I
> presume it would be cut or changed. Which simply means I
> do believe Ginny's patronus must be a phoenix. (The other
> option is that JKR had no patronus chosen for Ginny so
> let this one stand, but that's hard to believe.)

Alla:

Me too.

Julie: 
> I do find this annoying, because I really suspected a
> phoenix patronus might play a part in DH, and it would
> belong to either Harry or Snape, Dumbledore's Men (yes,
> I'm assuming on the latter!). Why Ginny would even 
> have a phoenix patronus I don't know (unless it comes
> to symbolize *Harry* in DH, which would make sense, but
> it doesn't make sense in OotP). 
> 
><SNIP>


Alla:

Well, Julie, who knows maybe you will get your wish and Harry and 
Snape will also have phoenixes as patronuses, you know? In fact 
maybe we will see many many phoenixes driving away the dementors.

MAHAHAHAHAHHAH. Phoenixes land, so to speak. Sorry, am annoyed, yes.

I do think it will be what you said - symbolising Harry, etc. Just 
in case we will not get the symbolism. I sort of prefer not so 
obvious symbolism. Sigh.