[HPFGU-Movie] Re: OOP movie SPOILER

[Susanne]

Hi,

Monday, April 16, 2007, 9:02:10 PM, justcarol67 at yahoo.com wrote:

> And I'm hoping that it will never be book canonical.
> It just makes no sense--unless it really does symbolize Fawkes's role
> in her rescue, and even then, Fawkes helped to rescue Harry, who
> rescued Ginny, so the Patronus should reflect Harry, not Dumbledore,
> and a Phoenix just doesn't do that, in my view.

But we've known that Ginny has a special role and JKR has let on that
we can expect a lot from her.

I just don't see why Ginny couldn't be powerful in
her own right and her patronus doesn't have to
have anything to do with her rescue or Harry.

HP is Harry's story, but the supporting characters
have their own lives and backgrounds.

Am I sensing a strong aversion toward Ginny?
Maybe that's why it seems like an insult that she
might have such a "prestigious" patronus?

-- 
Best regards,
 Susanne                           mailto:siskiou at peak.org