[HPFGU-Movie] Deleted scenes on the 2 disc set

[Karen]

Very disappointed in all the "extra scenes". Begh. Oh well. You get  
it for the movie, right? So far, not impressed with extras and think  
the packaging is flimsy. GOF at least had the cool outer box.

On Dec 16, 2007, at 9:03 AM, treeshahmom280 wrote:

> Okay folks, my question today is:  would some of these scenes
> worth cutting or would they have worked in the final cut?
>
> Trelawney at the opening feast:  I thought this was just bizarre
> and am glad it didn't make the final cut.  It just got goofier and
> goofier.  Once she stuck her hands in her drink, I just forwarded
> to the next scene.  I guess she is supposed to be "seeing" what
> Umbridge will be bringing along later, but this just creeped me
> out.
>
> Neville explaining that his Gran cancelled her subscription to the
> Daily Prophet after Seamus has words with Harry... that could
> have been left in, it was so short, those few seconds would have
> been okay.
>
> The extended visit of Umbridge to Trelawney's Divination class, I
> would have liked seeing in the final cut, not just the short bits of
> Umbridge all around school.
>
> Harry packing up at the end of term and Ron asking about final
> banquet, that would have been good in the final cut, showing just
> how isolated Harry feels right now.  Same with Harry alone in the
> commom room while others are playing cards, etc. This would
> not have added too much time to the final cut.
>
> Umbridge, Harry and Hermione in the Dark Forest:  Her
> extended speech about "I really hate children" would have been
> more effective if they had left this all in.
>
> Any other opinions?  Curious to hear what all you guys have on
> this.  Also, what did you think of the Trailing Tonks piece?  (I have
> mixed feelings on this one) and The Hidden Secrets of Harry
> Potter piece. (I think this is the same thing I saw on A&E the
> week the film was out in July?  This I thought was well done.)
>
> Thanks.
>
> Trish in NM (still relatively new to this group!)
>
>
>
>
> Remember to snip unnecessary material from posts to which you're  
> replying!
>
> Any questions or problems - contact the List Elves at HPforGrownups- 
> owner at yahoogroups.com
>
>
> Yahoo! Groups Links
>
>
>

___________________

http://pearlthediabeticcat.blogspot.com/