anyone who read the books too, answer me!

apetersonhanson apetersonhanson at yahoo.com
Sun Dec 16 15:52:48 UTC 2007


In the book OOP there are those 2 mirrors that Sirius gives Harry
and if Harry had bothered to check them then he would not have
rushed off to "save" Sirius in the dept of mysteries.  This is
tragic to me and the mirrors arent even in the movie!

Now, also in the book OOP, when everyone is cleaning up 12 g place
and making it proper for living in/using as the headquarters for the
ootp, they find the slytherin locket and all try to open it and
cant. Then Mundungus steals it.  Now we find out in DH (book 7) that
that was the locket from the cave and the one that RAB had switched
out.  Regulus ordered Kreacher to get it and come home and then he
went back to the cave to place the phony one and was killed by the
inferi.  Now the fact that the locket first shows up in OOP is
important because it is how the trio find it to destroy it in DH.
In the movie the locket is never seen.  This is just wrong to me.

In the movie when Harry tries to use the cruciatus curse on
Bellatrix, we hear LV's voice saying you have to mean it Harry.
Now, in the book the cruciatus curse doesn't work, Harry is puzzled
then Bella laughs and says you have to mean it boy, here I will show
you, and proceeds to use the curse correctly. The scene in the movie
is slightly different as I pointed out above and there was no need
to change it.


Did anyone else notice anything else that I missed?

alicia




More information about the HPFGU-Movie archive