[HPFGU-Movie] Getting it right in the films

[Valerie Flowe]

>  Valerie:
>  Neville with the gillyweed instead of Dobby.
>
>  Carol:
>  Right. Since Dobby is eliminated along with Winky, it looks as if
>  Neville broke into Snape's "stores" to steal the gillyweed!
>  ("Detention, Longbottom, and five hundred points from Gryffindor if I
>  catch you in my stores again!")
>
>  Valerie:
For some reason I assumed Neville came across the gillyweed slogging 
around in the black lake. But Snape did say it was a rare herb. Yet 
another hole in the altered plot there.
>
>  Carol, who thinks that the films will have to be remade in about ten
>  or fifteen years (with one director and one scriptwriter for the
>  entire series) to eliminate inconsitencies and gaps from one film to
>  the next
>
Valerie:
I'd hate to see other actors in these roles, because the current actors 
will always be the 'true characters' to me. But a nice BBC mini-series 
of all 7 books in full detail would be awesome! :-)