[HPFGU-Movie] Getting it right in the films

[Crystal Williams]

Same here, but a BBC mini-series, ohhh that would be soo awesome! It needs to be played by actors who have ALL read the books though. I'm hoping someone decent will remake the movies in about 15 years. 

Valerie Flowe <valerie.flowe at verizon.net> wrote:          > Valerie:
> Neville with the gillyweed instead of Dobby.
>
> Carol:
> Right. Since Dobby is eliminated along with Winky, it looks as if
> Neville broke into Snape's "stores" to steal the gillyweed!
> ("Detention, Longbottom, and five hundred points from Gryffindor if I
> catch you in my stores again!")
>
> Valerie:
For some reason I assumed Neville came across the gillyweed slogging 
around in the black lake. But Snape did say it was a rare herb. Yet 
another hole in the altered plot there.
>
> Carol, who thinks that the films will have to be remade in about ten
> or fifteen years (with one director and one scriptwriter for the
> entire series) to eliminate inconsitencies and gaps from one film to
> the next
>
Valerie:
I'd hate to see other actors in these roles, because the current actors 
will always be the 'true characters' to me. But a nice BBC mini-series 
of all 7 books in full detail would be awesome! :-)



                         

 __________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Tired of spam?  Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around 
http://mail.yahoo.com 

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]