Half-Blood Prince Date change - new picture (make that plural)

Carol justcarol67 at yahoo.com
Tue Aug 19 02:58:13 UTC 2008


Carol wrote:
>  
> > As for the Gaunts, I suspect that DD will tell Harry that Tom
framed his Muggle-hating uncle (not necessarily named) for the murder
of his (Tom's) Muggle father and took a ring--this ring (camera zooms
in to show the ring DD is wearing)--from his uncle's hand.
 
> zanooda:
> 
> Yeah, there is no problem with the ring, it's right there, on DD's
finger :-). It's the locket (and the cup :-)) that I have a problem
with :-). Harry needs to see these objects to be able to identify them
later in DH. Just talk about them is not enough for me ;-(.

Carol:
You're right. That's a real problem. And they missed the opportunity
to show the locket in OoP. Oh, bother! as Winnie the Pooh would say.
How in the world can they get themselves out of this mess, and why did
they add an unneeded scene at the expense of important ones? And
there's no Mundungus Fletcher, either, which messes up the locket
subplot in DH.

Carol, who suspects that Harry won't know what the real locket looks
like and will only learn that this one is fake when it falls open 







More information about the HPFGU-Movie archive