[HPFGU-Movie] Re: Seeing OOTP

[Andrea Grevera]

  . 
  Carol,
  It just hit me this morning when I was on the eliptical, watching some 
  of OOTP, the entire fairly huge thread about Luna's dad, the Quibbler, 
  Rita's comeback, the INTERVIEW, all of it, POOF! GONE! I know that if 
  it took me this long, then maybe it wasn't important, at least some 
  might say that, but no. When you are watching this rocket-paced movie, 
  you don't have any time to think, think about what should have been, 
  because this version comes at you like gangbusters. The more I think of 
  it, the more I realize making the book into a film was a crazy idea!
  Jen D. (at least I am on the elilptical when I am making these 
  discoveries!)

  Andie,

  I agree this picture was too fast, too short and too chopped up.  They didn't need Rita - Luna could have taken notes and sent them back to dad but it was another way the Harry tried getting his story out.  They also needed to include prefects, a better way to show Snapes worst memory, St. Mungo's, etc...  I've only watched it twice.  To me except for the first 2 movies the rest have been lacking too much of the storyline to really enjoy.





   

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]