Two WTF moments in the movie (spoilers)

[kennyg1864]

--- In HPFGU-Movie at yahoogroups.com, "Carol" <justcarol67 at ...> wrote:

> Carol again:

> Besides, Harry doesn't need to be told that there's a big black cabinet in B and B; he hid inside it in CoS 

If we're sticking to "movie canon", in CoS he hid inside an black Egyptian sarcophagus.  It may or may not have been a VC, but it wasn't referred to as such in the movie.  The CoS sarcophagus looked way different from the HBP VC, but heck, within "movie canon" Hagrid's Hut moves around, so who knows if it's supposed to be the "same" VC.

But even if it was a VC, *Harry* didn't know what it was at the time of CoS, other than a place to hide while Lucius sold off dark objects he didn't want in Malfoy Manor, even hidden.


> (a scene included in the extended version of the DVD)

I believe you mean "additional scenes"; there isn't an extended version per se, at least not on the released DVD.

kennyg1864, who suddenly has a great idea for profitable-but-illegal DVD's

and who wonders if the "THAT one is not for sale" object was the diary