Two WTF moments in the movie (spoilers)

Carol justcarol67 at yahoo.com
Sun Jul 26 21:01:52 UTC 2009


Carol earlier:
> > (a scene included in the extended version of the DVD)

kenny wrote:
 > I believe you mean "additional scenes"; there isn't an extended version per se, at least not on the released DVD.

Carol responds:
Yes and no. As I explained in another post, I meant the extended version as shown on TV (which I assumed was included in the later versions of the DVD). It's in the cut scenes on my old two-disk version. I guess the extended version DVDs will come out as a set after DH2.

> kennyg1864, who wonders if the "THAT one is not for sale" object was the diary
>
Carol responds:
The diary? I don't understand. Tom Riddle bought the diary in a Muggle shop fifty years before CoS, and Harry destroyed it with the Basilisk fang at the end of both the film and the book. I'm sure that it refers to the Vanishing Cabinet, the only object that there are two of.

Carol, not sure whether you're referring to CoS or HBP here or whether you mean the book or the film





More information about the HPFGU-Movie archive