Character concordances

leslesaja lesaja at gmx.de
Thu Jan 3 12:08:21 UTC 2002


in HPforGrownUps Elizabeth Dalton wrote:

> Have "concordances" quoting all the canon descriptions and dialogue 
of certain
> significant lesser characters been created, as far as anyone knows? 
Snape would
> be the most obvious one, I would think, but it would be interesting 
to do this
> for McGonnagal, as well, or perhaps Dumbledore. Scabbers/Pettigrew 
could be
> fascinating, too. And Neville probably needs this treatment the 
most.
> 
> My reasoning is that bundling all the canon details of some of
these 
characters
> together in one place might help us to see some of them more 
clearly. (Canon
> would here include both the books and interview transcripts.)
> 
> This makes less sense for Sirius or Lupin, as they are primarily 
described and
> appear in large cohesive sections of one or two books, but might 
make more sense
> going forward.
> 
> Elizabeth
> (who keeps wanting to think Snape is really better at heart than he 
seems, or
> McGonnagal more significant, but keeps coming up against 
descriptions otherwise
> in canon)
> 


I don't know if something like this does already exist.
I would find it very useful, too, and so I've started to do this for 
myself according to 1) Snape and 2) the Dark Arts.
I'm nearly through with PS and have already picked out the first 
relevant pages of CoS.

Because it's a lot of work, I would be glad if some one would like to
help - is anybody interested to?

I use the bloomsbury paperbacks that are available in germany.

Please e-mail me! Lesaja at gmx.de

LesAJa






More information about the HPFGU-OTChatter archive