Help deciding on a great part from HP

erisedstraeh2002 erisedstraeh2002 at yahoo.com
Wed Oct 16 21:08:36 UTC 2002


Richelle wrote:

> Help!  I've decided it might be nice to read a portion from one of 
> the HP books when I do the "literary festival" thing on Halloween 
> (i.e. dress up as Hermione Granger!)  What scene would be really 
> vivid when read aloud? That involves Hermione?  That a four year 
> old could comprehend?  Yes, I'm asking a lot.   

Now me:

I would have to say that IMO Hermione's finest hour was when she 
deciphered Snape's potion riddle at the end of PS/SS.  I also love 
how she tells Harry that he's a great wizard at the end of that scene 
and that bravery and friendship are more important than books and 
cleverness.

Probably not on a four-year old comprehension level, however, but JKR 
has said that her books weren't meant for anyone younger than 8, so 
I'm not sure you're going to find an appropriate passage for 4 year 
olds.  You may need to reword it yourself into language 4 year olds 
can understand.

~Phyllis





More information about the HPFGU-OTChatter archive