OoP, first impressions, part 1

[M.Clifford]

--- In HPFGU-OTChatter at yahoogroups.com, "mochajava13" 
<mochajava13 at y...> wrote:
> --- In HPFGU-OTChatter at yahoogroups.com, "Amanda Geist" 
<editor at t...> 
> wrote:
> > I
> > W
> > A
> > N
> > T
> > B
> > O
> > O
> > K
> > S
> > I
> > X
> > T
> > O
> > M
> > O
> > R
> > R
> > O
> > W
> > 
> > I would personally like to knock Harry in the head for not 
> apologizing to
> > Snape after that. Seriously. Honestly. I can understand not 
> thanking him,
> > when you're eleven, for not saving your life--but at fifteen, 
when 
> you've
> > just stuck your head into a memory he removed for the explicit 
> purpose of
> > preventing you seeing it, and discovered he'd possibly had a 
point 
> in what
> > he'd been telling you and not *only* being nasty, and have been 
in 
> exactly
> > that position and realize the sort of personal area you're 
> treading on....I
> > *refuse* to condone Harry's total lack of any kind of remorse for 
> this.
> 
> 
> I felt that Harry was remorseful about invading Snape's private 
> space, and for what he saw in Snape's thoughts.   I think Harry 
> tried to tell Snape that he didn't find his father's actions 
> amusing, and that Snape kicked Harry out of his office before Harry 
> could explain.  And I do think that since Snape is the adult, not 
> Harry, Snape shouldn't have stopped the Occlumency lessons.  
> Espcially since Dumbledore specifically asked him to resume them.  
> Would Sirius have died if Snape had continued these lessons?

Blub Blub Blub... Valky wipes her sodden eyes, Siriussss... sniff 
sniff.
Darn it didnt she have us all wacked though eh. Hagrid then Hagrid 
again Macgonagall, Sirius, all the DA, Hermione, Ron, Neville, Moody, 
then finally boo hoo Sirius waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa. Then, to top it all 
off she threatens to kill off Dumbledore and Harry in one hit. Oh 
waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa I am soooo sad about Sirius.
Sorry, composure. sniff sniff.
I put the book down and walked out when I thought it was Hermione. I 
thought, How can I read this to my Daughter? 
About dying, I dont think that Harry should even have gone to the MOM 
at all the prophecy was useless to anybody. Voldemort may as well 
have written it himself for all the use it was to him now. I think 
that there was confusion among the ranks. I dont think that they were 
actually guarding the prophecy at all.
I am sure they thought that Voldemort was after something much more 
powerful. 
It was all a very sorry and sad mess.
Valky