Just sharing - thoughts on the transcript

Amy Z lupinesque at yahoo.com
Fri Mar 5 00:33:09 UTC 2004


Joywitch wrote:

> I 
> don't care what JKR says, Snape *IS* too a vampire.

Take heart.  If Heidi can wring H/D out of that emphatic denial, 
I'm sure she can stitch you a vampire cloak for Snape out of thin 
air.  

*I* would like to gloat about her clear statement that Ginny has a 
personality.  I think it was abundantly obvious in OoP even to 
those who couldn't see it before then, but given that some 
people will not abandon their conviction that Ginny has the 
personality of a wet dishcloth, it's particularly satisfying to have 
JKR point out the same evidence we Ginny-defenders have been 
pointing out for years, e.g. that Ron says *back in CoS* that she 
normally "never shuts up."
 
> --Joywitch, who is glad to see the goat galloping around

Amy, ditto

and who also wonders if JKR just makes up things like "the J is 
for John" and "the P is for Patricia" on the spot, or actually has 
this kind of trivia already recorded in the famed notebooks





More information about the HPFGU-OTChatter archive