Just sharing - thoughts on the transcript
davewitley
dfrankiswork at netscape.net
Sat Mar 6 00:13:17 UTC 2004
Amy:
> *I* would like to gloat about her clear statement that Ginny has a
> personality. I think it was abundantly obvious in OoP even to
> those who couldn't see it before then, but given that some
> people will not abandon their conviction that Ginny has the
> personality of a wet dishcloth, it's particularly satisfying to
have
> JKR point out the same evidence we Ginny-defenders have been
> pointing out for years, e.g. that Ron says *back in CoS* that she
> normally "never shuts up."
Not to mention those who claim that Ginny *had* the personality of a
wet dishcloth until OOP, and then suddenly changed, and therefore
must be a badly-written character.
> and who also wonders if JKR just makes up things like "the J is
> for John" and "the P is for Patricia" on the spot, or actually has
> this kind of trivia already recorded in the famed notebooks
Yes, I wonder that, too, though unless Jessica catches a touch of
the Christopher Tolkiens, it seems we'll never know
David
More information about the HPFGU-OTChatter
archive