[HPFGU-OTChatter] Re: New FAQ poll

[kemper mentor]

Valky wrote:
  
... I'd like to put forward my opinion on the
new questions. 
   
  1) What happens to a secret when the secret keeper dies?
2)Does the destruction of a horcrux involve more than the destruction of the object?
3)Why did Voldemort want the Philosophers Stone if he already had his horcruxes?
   
  I Really really really hope that Number two gets's
voted in. There are some reasons I think this would be the most
profitable quetion for us to ask on this opportunity and they are 
- Dumbledore answered, for the most part, number three in the
Horcruxes chapter of HBP. At least half of this answer to this won't
be new to us. 

I speak possibly too boldly but I would guess that many of us here in
HPFGU are tossing up between one and two, they are both very tempting,
but I don't think we should ask for the answer to number one. Because
it's about the Order of the Phoenix, not trying to be sarcastic, but
probably coming off that way, book seven isn't going to be caled Harry
poter and the Order of the Phoenix, that *was* book five. IMO the only
real book seven question is question two. 

That's just my humble opinion and your prerogative to vote the way you
like, enjoy. 

   
  
Kemper now:
  I agree with Valky.  Question 2 seems to offer the most.  I would also add that the answer to Question 1 may be irrelevant should DD be alive.  Q1 looks like a fresh way to throw us off scent.  The question doesn't ask "What will happen to 12 grimaould place now that Dumbledore, the Secret Keeper, is dead?"  I know there is plenty of canon to support Dumbledore's death, but I live in possibility.  Schoedinger's cat anyone?
   
  Happy Whatever to all.
   
  -Kemper
   
   

		
---------------------------------
Yahoo! Photos
 Ring in the New Year with Photo Calendars. Add photos, events, holidays, whatever.

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]