Book 6 survey

[juli17 at aol.com]

Katherine wrote:


> 8) Is  Harry's scar a horcrux?

K:  I hope not.   I think it is  something like horcrux backwash.  
Basically, LV had already split his  soul so much that when the AK 
backfired and almost killed him, some of his  traits and talents 
rebounded into Harry.

OR:

Snape told  Dumbledore that LV intended to make Harry a Horcrux and LV 
and Snape spent  the Famous Missing 24 Hours destroying the Horcrux part 
of Harry already,  thus leaving him with the scar.   This could also be 
the reason  why DD trusts Snape.


Julie says:
Now that is a really inventive theory! I'm trying to recall if there was  any 
mention of the scar appearing at the moment Voldemort tried to AK  Harry. 
The only problem I see is that Dumbeldore told Harry only two of the 
horcruxes had been destroyed--the one in the diary and the one  in
the ring. Why wouldn't he mention the destruction of this third one?
 
Julie 


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]