"Only just".

zanooda2 zanooda2 at yahoo.com
Sat Dec 13 01:32:17 UTC 2008


--- In HPFGU-OTChatter at yahoogroups.com, Sue Wartell <swartell at ...> 
wrote:

> Ron had suggested that she say she was waiting for Flitwick 
> to ask about a question on her exam.  That suggests to me that 
> she hadn't yet heard about her results before she went off to 
> watch for Snape.  Hermione is a detail-oriented person, and a 
> stickler for precision and correct answers, and I think she 
> would have objected to that particular excuse if she already 
> had been told her results.  


zanooda:

This a very good argument, and I don't know why I didn't think about 
it myself. 112% was one of the reasons I believed that Hermione 
indeed talked to Flitwick, but OTOH I wasn't sure. I kind of thought 
it's possible that Flitwick told her about her grade some other time, 
because his exam was not the last one, and they didn't take it that 
same day. 

But you are right of course - when Ron suggests Hermione should tell 
Flitwick she is worried about some exam question, she doesn't say 
that it wouldn't work and that she already knows her grade. This 
means Hermione talked to Flitwick outside the staff room, and Snape 
meanwhile left, and she didn't know where he went.





More information about the HPFGU-OTChatter archive