Snape's death scene WAS Re: Sweeney Todd? Bloody Hell!

Carol justcarol67 at yahoo.com
Tue Feb 19 22:52:41 UTC 2008


-
> Although actually come to think of it, we do not know if she eats 
him or not, because Snape's body is left in the Shack and for all I 
know she may have come back and eat him whole, although this is a 
total speculation and not in the books of course.
> 
Carol:
Fortunately not. Neville kills Nagini, remember? She never reenters
the Shrieking Shack or anywhere else, thank goodness!
> 

Carol:
> > So I think she'll strike once, drawing enough bolld [erm, blood.
Why can't I type that word?]for him to bleed to death (though the
audience may think it's the venom that kills him). It doesn't have to
be graphic, just effective. 
> 
> Alla:
> 
> And that was my point, how to make it easy on the eyes, which I 
agree most likely will be shown, although if we think of the huge IMO
amount of the important scenes that were omitted, I am not so sure
that the picture of Nagini striking will be there necessarily IMO.
> 
Carol:
Well, they'll need to make it clear that he's killed by the snake and
not by a spell, and he has to release the memories and ask Harry to
look into his eyes, so I don't see how they'll avoid showing the
blood. It will be a scary and horrifying scene even if they treat it
like Nagini's biting Mr. Weasley in the OoP film. (Not as horrific as
Bathilda!Nagini, though. I wonder if they'll show that?)
> 
> Carol:
> And snape, as I said, has to have that last interaction with Harry
after Nagini 
> leaves.
> 
> Alla:
> 
> Sure, unless they decide to cut it out, but if they do not, I think
it is totally Okay for example if Trio comes upon Snape already 
bleeding and then he gives the memories. Not that I care one way or 
another, I mean, I do in a sense that I am easily scared LOL, but I
can close my eyes if I wish.

Carol responds:
I don't see how they can cut that scene, if only because it leads to
the Pensieve scene, which is Harry's reason for sacrificing himself
rather than trying to kill Voldemort. I also think that the whole
atonement/remorse/forgiveness/forswearing vengeance theme is crucial
and without Snape's death and Harry's forgiveness of him, that crucial
element is missing.

But, yeah. You can close your eyes, and I expect you'll want to more
than once. Even in HBP, there's the scene with the Inferi. And imagine
if they depict Regulus's death in the DH film. The Inferi actually
pull him into the water. Poor Regulus! At least his brother got an
easy death.
> 
> 
> My question was how they can show it to make it easier for those who 
> are easily scared and actually I think Pippin's answer is very 
> possible. If they show it as a shadow, I will be very happy and vou 
> la then Snape can have his last interaction with  Harry.

Carol:
Yes. Voile! And, speaking of easily scared, I wonder how they can make
these films, especially DH, suitable for viewers under nine or so
without ruining them for adults. (BTW, I didn't find the OoP Dementors
scary at all. The ones in PoA, with their scabby hands, were much
scarier.)
> 
> CArol:
> > I can't imagine them not showing Snape's death scene, which is
crucial to the plot. <SNIP>
> 
> Alla:
> 
> And you are most likely right, but I am not sure at all that bite 
> will be shown in all its glory necessarily.
>
Carol:
Then we agree. I think Snape's head being pulled into the bubble will
be scary enough, thank you!

Carol, imagining herself screaming like a little kid in the theater
and embarrassing everybody





More information about the HPFGU-OTChatter archive