[HPFGU-OTChatter] HP Ultimate Editions

[No Limberger]

>md wrote:

>The first two films include extended versions, these are worth having,
>however, 3 and 4 only contain one extra disk of extras and no extended
>versions of the films, so no, not worth it IMO. WB was promising extended
>versions of ALL the films, why they didn't deliver I can't imagine. I got
>part 3 before I knew they had not included an extended version and I'm
>really pissed.

No.Limberger responds:

Since I always prefer to watch an extended version of a film over the
theatrical release, I was very happy with the Ultimate Editions of
SS and CoS including extended versions of the films. I had also believed
that the Ultimate Editions of PoA and GoF would also include the
extended versions. When I realized that they didn't, I was extremely
disappointed, especially with no GoF extended version given how much
additional material is in the deleted scenes (not so much with PoA).

I don't know why WB didn't include extended versions of PoA & GoF
in the Ultimate Editions, but I have speculated about this after watching
the extended version of Avatar. There are a lot of deleted & incomplete
scenes in Avatar. The incomplete scenes are in various stages of
completion. None of them are included in the extended version, which
includes all of the completed deleted scenes. This lead me to wonder
if WB regards the deleted scenes in PoA and GoF to be insufficiently
complete to have been included in an extended version.

-- 
"Why don't you dance with me, I'm not no limberger!"


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]