Lily's family history

[davehoz]

Original Yahoo! HPFG Header:
No: HPFGUIDX C5009
From: davehoz
Subject: Re: Lily's family history
Reply To: [Yahoo! #5003] Lily's family history
Date: 7/24/00 8:02 pm  (ET)

There are three subtheories (that I've heard) to the "Petunia is really
a squib in a wizard family" theory, based on possible maiden names of
Lily and Petunia, namely that it is:

A) Lily and Petunia Riddle (The "Harry, I am your *grand*father" theory)

B) Lily and Petunia Weasley (In which case they really *are* Harry's
true family)

or (my personal favorite)

C) Lily and Petunia Snape (In which Severus wasn't *in love* with Lily
but was her over-protective older brother, who hates James for "carrying
her off" and Voldemort for killing her, which he blames James for too.)