Some Annoying SS (or PS) Questions

[davehoz]

Original Yahoo! HPFG Header:
No: HPFGUIDX C2960
From: davehoz
Subject: Re: Some Annoying SS (or PS) Questions
Reply To: [Yahoo! #2938] Re: Some Annoying SS (or PS) Questions
Date: 6/28/00 2:12 am  (ET)

>I'm not surprised the chess set was ready for another game after Quirrell
passed it...

What gets me is why did Hermione say, "McGonnegal transfigured the chess
men to make them alive"? *All* wizard chess men are alive! Isn't what
Minerva did was to make them life-size?

>I suppose Snape could have put a spell on the bottles to refill and
>replace themselves after being used, but would he have done so? Would
>he have seen the need to add "that foolish wand waving"?

Maybe Flitwick did it.

> I almost wished Rowling had included a picture of
>the line of bottles, so I could attempt that logic problem myself!

I haven't gone through it, but is a picture necessary?

BTW, I wonder who contributed the logic puzzle itself... Dumbledore?