[HPforGrownups] Mystery parallels

Stephanie Becvar StephBecvar at hotmail.com
Mon Dec 18 04:41:31 UTC 2000


No: HPFGUIDX 7198

>Has anyone ever discussed the way that the Potter books seem to work
>kind of like mysteries in that there's often some sort of crime or
>shady activity going around, with the true culprit later being
>exposed. It seems like one of the truths of the series is that it's
>always the least likely person. (This might get to be a problem
>later, as everyone gets used to the pattern).
>Has anyone ever anticipated the twist? (I never have, at least so
>far).
>
>Charmian

Actually, I got the pattern in book 1, mainly bc i am used to books with a 
twist, and i noticed Prf Quirrell was everywhere, and the scenes where he 
was arguing with snape he didnt seem to me to be so nervous.  And in book 4, 
I knew it wouldnt be Krum, And i suspected Mad Eye, but i never caught the 
whole son part of it....that was a pretty crazy twist.  I love how you get 
to the resolution and say "Oy...why did i not see that, she made it so 
obvious"...but it is only obvious once you know the ending.  There are so 
many ways she could do it and it is great.  Books for me were so mundane and 
predictable lately, which is a big part of why i enjoy the HP series as much 
as I do!

Stephanie

_________________________________________________________________
Get your FREE download of MSN Explorer at http://explorer.msn.com





More information about the HPforGrownups archive